data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3ca6f/3ca6f6c382002cd2196dbf0afdd6820f6563884c" alt=""
Review: God, why did I wait so long to read this book??!! Was I afraid it wouldn't be as good as The Winter Rose
I LOVED learning about her background. I loved the background of her and Joe's life. Most of all I loved that she was a girl beyond the time period she lived in. I do think there were more woman like this than we will ever here of in history books. Not all woman wanted to cook, clean and have babies. Not that there is anything wrong with that but women today wouldn't be where we are without woman like Fiona Finnegan. She grew up poor, had tragedy after tragedy in her young life and yet escaped and made something of herself in the land of opportunity...America. Do I think Fiona was lucky and maybe parts of the book were unrealistic, probably, but that didn't change my mind about the book. The secondary characters in the book were wonderful, colorful and absolutely necessary to her story and this was Fiona's story. Joe is an integral part of it but it's a woman's story, not a man's.
I loved the romance in the book. Most of all I loved the vivid details of London and NYC during the late 1800s. What a time period to write about, so much rich history and such different history to draw upon. Ms. Donnelly does such an excellent job of describing both Whitechapel and NYC that you feel like you are there. I especially liked the descriptions of the fashion.
I also liked the idea that family is what you make it, because for some people family isn't necessarily blood, it's the relationships you cultivate.
I strongly encourage you to pick up both The Tea Rose and The Winter Rose for your reading pleasure. With the anticipation that the 3rd book in the series The Wild Rose is due out in 2010!! I will more than likely read The Winter Rose before the
last in the trilogy comes out. This is my 3rd Jennifer Donnelly book and I can say she has made it to my favorite author list.
Final Take: 5/5
Lisa's Review: The Tea Rose
Winter Rose Reviews: Lisa's Review: The Winter Rose & Julie's Review: The Winter Rose
3 comments:
This book has been sitting on my bookshelf FOREVER! I really have to pick it up soon!
You won't regret it! It's wonderful.
I liked this book a lot, LOVED The Winter Rose and now I am waiting very impatiently for The Wild Rose!
Post a Comment